Yearly Archives: 2015

An End to the Centre-Periphery Game? Arts and the Media in Wales


David Anderson , Director General of Amgueddfa Cymru takes the BBC to task for its poor coverage of arts and culture in Wales. In a hard-hitting article in the latest edition of the IWA’s ‘The Welsh Agenda’ magazine he analyses how what he calls ‘The Centre-Periphery Game’ has encouraged this shortcoming, exacerbating a failure of perception on the part of the BBC centrally but also a failure of the arts community in Wales to challenge the status quo.

Continue reading An End to the Centre-Periphery Game? Arts and the Media in Wales

Is the BBC Trust getting the message from Wales?

The BBC Trust held a seminar in Cardiff ‘as part of the Charter review process’ on 20th October. It was open to the public but the majority of those present were media workers, academics or correspondents. The Western Mail report on it is accurate but conveys nothing of the atmosphere among the attendees which was, at times, mutinous and, finally, outspokenly critical. These sore spots have to be examined or they will go on festering to no good purpose.


Continue reading Is the BBC Trust getting the message from Wales?

IWA Media Audit – Dialogue and Debate



Throughout the past week the Media Policy Group of the Institute of Welsh Affairs has been publishing its draft analysis of the state of main media sectors in Wales. This approach has allowed us to receive valuable feedback on our chapters on the radio industry and the press that will be incorporated into the final report. This will be launched at the Cardiff Media Summit on November 11th. We have also had the benefit of expert comment pieces carried on the IWA site and look forward to more. It is proving to be a good experience of dialogue around these important issues and of the kind of debate about them that has long been called for in Wales.

The analysis we have laid out is sobering. Continue reading IWA Media Audit – Dialogue and Debate

Ankylosing Spondylitis – National Arthritis Day in Cardiff

Cardiff NASS Group

I think we are supposed to be high-fiving but we look more like a weird chorus line. Every Wednesday evening for more than a decade I’ve been in either the pool or the gym at University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff along with a dedicated band of exercisers. What unites us is a particular type of arthritic condition called Ankylosing Spondylitis. Without exercise we’d all seize up and our posture would resemble the curve of a palm tree.

On World Arthritis Day I’d like to say a big thank you to all of my fellow sufferers in the Cardiff group of the National Ankylosing Spondylitis Society. When I joined the group I could just about walk. I will always remember how, during my first session, one of them had to pull me to my feet from the floor where we were doing exercises. He was so understanding. I realised I was with people who knew what I was going through and it was the example of their cheerfulness as much as their practical advice that helped me to improve. Without the group I wouldn’t have known about various resources and possibilities.

As the years have gone by, we’ve shared symptoms, set-backs and progress. And tragedy. One of the group died needlessly because of a chain of circumstances and lack of understanding of the condition. Basically, in someone who is badly afflicted, the spine can fuse into a single ‘stem’, hence the palm tree analogy. Movement between the vertebrae is extremely limited. Our poor friend was roughly handled by public servants who should have known better and he died of a broken back. His case contributed to a raising of awareness of the condition but was too heavy a price to pay.

Another group member died this summer, Chris Thorkelson. He lived in my street and I admired his indomitable courage as, despite progressive challenges, he tried ever new ways of getting around and doing his bit.

We have fun in our weekly exercise sessions which are led by a rota of dedicated physiotherapists and now and then we fund raise for the charity, the National Ankylosing Spondylitis Society. Our sponsored walks are never the fastest race around the park but they’re very good humoured!

Thanks also to the Rheumatology Department at UHW and to the specialist AS physios there who keep us moving. It’s the NHS at its best. We are patients who will seldom be ‘cured’ but we respond very well to ‘management training’.   At least AS is a condition in which one can influence the impact of the symptoms by appropriate regular exercise and understanding of potential treatments.

It can be a frightening condition. One of the possible facets is iritis, inflammation of the iris, which is excruciatingly painful and can cause blindness if not treated promptly; also psoriatric symptoms and intense fatigue.

For these reasons also the camaraderie of a NASS group such as ours is enormously helpful.


British, Bold, Creative – for all of us in Wales?

British, Bold, Creative: a catchy, punchy title for the BBC’s statement of its plans for the next decade and beyond but, read from the point of view of the Welsh bit of ‘British’, the contents are something of a curate’s egg.

Lord Hall

One sees the effort to engage with the Nations and Regions. There are suggestions about reconfiguring the delivery of news and about opening up platforms for a wider sharing of materials. The aspirations are right, as in section 7.3 Entertaining the whole UK:

Firstly, we will improve how we portray and represent the different Nations of the UK on our pan-UK network services. Secondly, we will strengthen the services for each Nation.

Then comes a very big ‘but’:

But significant new investment in a broader range of programming, such as drama, comedy and entertainment, cannot be delivered within the current Budget agreement with the Government… funding these ambitions would require additional income. Continue reading British, Bold, Creative – for all of us in Wales?

Broadcasting for the Nations

Broadcasting for the nations – on the agenda at last

C Jones

 The First Minister’s letter to the BBC shows a new urgency on the plight of Welsh broadcasting. August  2015

The Welsh Government’s decision to go for broke by demanding an extra £30m from the BBC licence for broadcasting in Wales, is a matter for both relief and rejoicing. In the last decade it has been strangely reluctant to take up the issue of service deficiencies in Wales. In the face of the decline of the ITV service, unending cuts at BBC Wales and reductions in S4C funding it has been tepid in its responses to calls for action by both the Institute of Welsh Affairs and the National Assembly’s own committees. Continue reading Broadcasting for the Nations

Beyond Rhetoric – IWA Media Policy for Wales


“as slow to be set on fire as a stomach”

I wondered, while listening to Rhodri Talfan Davies speak this week on two occasions at the National Eisteddfod, if some version of that sentiment ever entered his mind. It certainly entered mine. It’s a striking phrase coined by George Eliot to express her frustration at her contemporaries’ failure to grasp the spirit of the times. How slow we are – those of us not touched by genius such as hers   ̶   to see the writing on the cultural wall in front of us. A new dispensation is coming and we need the ideas to meet it.

National Eisteddfod - Eisteddfod Genedlaethol Cymru Llanelli 2014

Continue reading Beyond Rhetoric – IWA Media Policy for Wales